Car insurance in Orangeville

As you navigate through Orangeville's quaint downtown, you'll find an array of charming shops, cozy cafes, and delicious eateries, making it an ideal destination for a leisurely stroll and some retail therapy. Ensure your peace of mind when traveling around Orangeville by securing comprehensive car insurance with BrokerLink.

Is car insurance mandatory in Orangeville?

Ultimately yes, car insurance in Orangeville is considered mandatory. Not all forms of car insurance coverage are required, such as comprehensive car coverage and collision car coverage, but depending on your scenario, some coverages are highly recommended.

In the province of Ontario, third-party liability insurance, accident benefits insurance, uninsured automobile coverage, and direct compensation property damage are mandatory coverages. , Beginning January 1, 2024, direct compensation property damage will no longer be a mandatory coverage, therefore, you will have the option to choose whether or not you wish to opt in. Working with an insurance broker will make apparent what coverages are needed given your circumstances, how you drive, and the make or model of your vehicle.

When it comes to car insurance in Orangeville, there are many options to consider when deciding. Many types of car insurance are mandatory, whereas others may not be needed depending on your scenario. A BrokerLink insurance advisor will be happy to walk you through your options and save you time by recommending the best policy for your needs.

What’s affecting my auto rates in Orangeville?

Car insurance in Orangeville is based on your own personal circumstances, so there are many factors that go into calculating your rates. BrokerLink, as an insurance broker, does not determine your rates but rather works with a number of insurance companies to find the best policy for your specific needs. We do believe, however, that it is critical for you to understand some of the key factors that may influence your insurance rates. Below are some of what may be impacting your auto insurance rates in Orangeville, for better or worse:

Your postal code

Where you live in Orangeville is a huge determinant of your car insurance rates. While Orangeville may have lower insurance rates than some other cities in Ontario, if you live in a high crime or high claim neighbourhood, your rates may be higher.

Age and experience

Newer, inexperienced drivers tend to pay more for their insurance than senior drivers with lots of experience behind the wheel. As you get older and get more experience, you may notice your rates start to lower when renewing your car insurance.

Driving record

Having multiple violations of traffic, law, speeding tickets, and other “black marks” on your insurance rates can cause your insurance rates to spike. Major violations, like driving under influences, can even land you a high-risk label and double or even triple your insurance costs.

Insurance coverage and deductibles

The kind of coverage you have, your policy limits, and your deductibles will play a role in your total costs. The more coverage you have and the higher your limits, the more your insurance will be. Having extra coverage options, such as accident forgiveness, may also add to your premiums.

The insured vehicle

The make and model of the insured vehicle, its condition, its age, and so on make impact your premiums. It tends to be that cars with a higher safety rating and lower theft likelihood cost less to insure. Also, the total value of the vehicle matters, as it will influence the potential total replacement cost in the event of a loss.

Types of car insurance coverage in Orangeville

There are many different types of car insurance in Orangeville, some mandatory and some not. Read on for a brief description of the kinds of car insurance you may encounter:

Liability insurance

Liability car insurance is perhaps the most important coverage on this list, as it protects you from any costs you are held liable for - such as medical expenses, repair costs, property damage, and so forth. It can help pay for any compensation third-parties are entitled to, plus it may cover legal costs if you are ever sued for any damages or injuries you caused while operating your vehicle.

Accident benefits

Accident benefits coverage provides coverage for injuries or even fatalities suffered in an insured accident, including the drivers, passengers, and even pedestrians on the road. It can cover costs like rehabilitation costs, funeral expenses, loss of income (if injured people are unable to return to work due to their injuries), medical treatments, and more.

Direct compensation property damage

Direct compensation property damage, or DCPD, a mandatory coverage that works with Ontario’s no-fault insurance system wherein if you are involved in an accident with another driver, no matter who is at-fault, you will seek compensation from your own insurance provider for the cost of damages/repairs.

Uninsured automobile coverage

Uninsured automobile coverage, or uninsured motorist coverage, is a type of coverage designed to cover you and your vehicle if you should ever get into an accident where the other party at-fault is under insured or uninsured. This may also apply in a hit-and-run situation, where the other vehicle was unable to be identified. This coverage includes compensation for repair or even replacement vehicle costs.

Collision coverage

Collision coverage, while optional, is a type of coverage designed to protect you from the costs of repairs or replacement, no matter who was at-fault in the accident. Collision coverage is subject to a deductible, so you will need to pay your deductible before your coverage kicks in to cover the remaining losses. For example, if your deductible is $500 and the damage to your vehicle is $1500, you are responsible for the first $500 and your insurance will kick in to cover the remaining $1000.

Comprehensive coverage

Also optional, comprehensive coverage may insure you against damages due to things unrelated to collisions, such as weather conditions such as hail, windstorms, ice storms, fire, theft and vandalism, and so forth. Even if you don’t drive your vehicle in certain seasons, or if your vehicle is away in storage, we recommend at least keeping comprehensive coverage to protect it from damages that may occur, such as fire or theft, even when it’s parked and not in-use.

What isn’t covered by car insurance in Orangeville?

Car insurance in Orangeville isn’t always a catch-all. Assuming you are covered for every possible damage can be dangerous, since it may result in you not fully understanding your coverage and could land you in a situation where you’re in the hole for lost costs. Here are some items that may not be covered by your car insurance in Orangeville:

Maintenance costs

Wear and tear costs or maintenance costs are not covered by insurance. This is because insurance, by nature, is designed to cover unexpected or accidental damages resulting in financial loss, like car accidents or freak weather events. You, as the owner or lessee of your vehicle, are responsible for maintenance costs and keeping your car in good working order.

Uninsurable perils

Not every peril is insurable. In certain provinces and areas, some perils are considered uninsurable due to the risk that is presented. For example, not all insurers will offer coverage for earthquakes, if the place where the policyholder lives is more prone to earthquakes. The same applies for flooding. If you are concerned about a certain peril, discuss it with your provider to see if coverage is an option and if it is offered by that insurer.

Commercial use

Driving for Uber or doing deliveries with your personal vehicle may disqualify you from coverage and can even void your insurance altogether. You may be able to avoid any penalties by acquiring a separate commercial insurance policy, which may also be offered by the company through which you do your deliveries or ride-sharing services. Another option can be an endorsement for business use on your personal policy, if the company decides that it fits their underwriting guidelines. Usually with both a commercial and personal policy, your commercial policy will cover you for commercial-based activities and your personal policy will cover you while using your vehicle for personal purposes.


While some modifications may be covered by your car insurance in Orangeville, not all will. Some modifications that may impact the safety rating of your vehicle, its speed, or its value beyond a certain limit will not be covered by your insurance - especially if they are not disclosed to your insurance provider.

How much does car insurance in Orangeville cost?

The average cost of car insurance in Orangeville, Ontario is around $1,700/year. Compared to Toronto car insurance, which can range well over $2000 a year, this cost estimate is in the middle-to-high average for auto insurance costs in the province of Ontario. The reason that costs for auto insurance in Orangeville might be lower are due to its lower population of approximately 30,000, In comparison to Toronto which has almost 3,000,000 residents.

Top tips for reducing rates on your car insurance in Orangeville, Ontario

Saving money on your auto insurance in Orangeville isn’t as cut-and-dry as simply “slashing coverage.” In fact, we highly recommend against cutting coverage as a means to save yourself money. Doing so can leave you vulnerable to losses, which in turn may actually end up costing you more money overall. Instead, we recommend working with an insurance broker to find specific cost-savings strategies to help reduce your rates. You may also take advantage of the following tips that we have described in-depth below:

Multi-policy discounts

Having multiple insurance policies through the same provider, even multiple auto insurance policies, can save you money. Why? Because insurers make a great deal of their business through existing customers, and they incentivize customers to purchase other policies through them by offering discounts. By bundling, for example, your home and auto policy through a single insurer, you may save on each policy.

Driving less

While it may seem contradictory, driving less can save you money on your car insurance. Some insurers will reward drivers from driving under specific thresholds, usually for 11,000km/year and under. If you already don’t drive very much, consider reducing your mileage further by opting for public transport, carpooling, biking, or walking to keep your costs lower.

Anti-theft alarms

Most car models nowadays come with pre-installed anti-theft alarms, and while purchasing one of these may help to qualify you for an anti-theft alarm discount, you may also choose to install an approved alarm system to qualify if your car already doesn’t have one.

Higher policy deductible

Choosing to raise your policy deductible, so long as doing so is financially feasible for you (i.e., you are able to pay for your deductible in the event of a claim) can help to lower your insurance premiums. With insurance, generally the case is that the higher your deductible, the lower your premium - and vice versa. This can be a great cost-saving strategy, and may also dissuade you from filing multiple small claims.

Paying annually for your insurance

Rather than paying for your auto insurance month-by-month, you may choose instead to pay annually or semi-annually (depending on if you have a 12 month or a 6 month term policy.) This may not only qualify you for a discount, but it can also slash the administrative fees that you may end up paying each month per policy payment. Over time, this could save you hundreds of dollars on your insurance payments!

Driver’s education courses

Especially for newer drivers, taking driver’s education courses can help to reduce the inflated costs you may end up paying for your insurance by being an inexperienced driver. Not all courses are approved, so make sure to ask your provider which ones are recognized and will qualify for a discount. Even if you are a more experienced driver, education courses can give you safe driving tips and refresh your knowledge to help keep you safer on the road.

Installing winter tires

Especially in Ontario, where the winter weather can be fierce, installing winter tires can help you to stay safer on the road and prevent nasty slips and accidents. Insurers view cars that are equipped with winter tires at the right time each year as less likely to be involved in a collision, and may reward drivers who do their due diligence with an insurance discount.

Why BrokerLink?

Whether you're purchasing your first car and searching for coverage that meets your individual needs, or you've been around the block before, there's always a benefit in working with a broker to ensure you obtain the coverage you need. We at BrokerLink specialize in a wide range of insurance products, and as self-proclaimed insurance geeks, we have all the knowledge you need to acquire the best coverage for all of your personal belongings.

We're in your community

Aside from offering all of the latest and best methods to save money, one wonderful benefit of selecting BrokerLink is that we have over 200+ branches throughout Canada, which means that one of your neighbours might very well be a BrokerLink insurance broker in Orangeville. We are really excited to meet our new neighbours in Orangeville. To get started, give us a call or email to receive a quote, or come see us in person.

Local Ontario Insurance Links

If you’re a member of a group or association, you may be eligible for more discounts.

Contact us

When you're ready to get started, contact BrokerLink by phone, email, or by visiting one of our local locations. We provide three methods to communicate because we recognize that addressing your insurance requirements the "traditional way" isn't always viable for everyone's hectic schedule. We are pleased to get to know you in whatever way you desire so that we can recommend the best insurance at the greatest price.

Get an auto insurance quote [phone]

Orangeville car insurance FAQs

We don't expect you to become an insurance expert. That is, after all, our job. We understand if you are unsure about what is covered by your policy and would gladly answer any queries you may have. We have listed and answered some of the most commonly asked questions by Orangeville residents below:

Why is auto insurance more expensive in Ontario?

Car insurance rates in Ontario are some of the highest in the country, which often leads to frustration among drivers. Unfortunately, there are multiple reasons for this, and narrowing it down to one particular reason may not justify the costs of your policy.

Another contributor is extreme weather, resulting in higher claim payouts. Storms, floods, and tornadoes in Ontario are causing extreme, unprecedented property losses and resulting in providers needing to raise their rates all across the board to ensure that they can keep making claim payouts without issue.

Finally, issues such as more expensive vehicles on the road, more distracted driving rates, and higher inflation rates are also contributing to expense rates in Ontario. Working with a BrokerLink broker may be the solution to help keep your rates in check.

Is DCPD optional for Ontario drivers?

As of January 1, 2024, drivers will be allowed to drop DCPD coverage from their policies. DCPD was initially a mandatory coverage as part of the Ontario Insurance Act, which allowed policyholders to find coverage from their own providers rather than having to pursue the other driver for repair damage in an event that was not their fault. This is part of Ontario’s no-fault insurance rule. However, this ruling is soon to change, as Ontario policyholders will now have the choice to drop their DCPD coverage.

While opting out of DCPD can reduce the cost of insurance premiums, leaving it out of your policy can cost you tremendously later if you find yourself underinsured in the event of an accident. If you opt out, you ultimately decline the no-fault component of auto insurance policies in Ontario. Opting out means you agree not to pursue compensation for damages from your own insurance provider should you be involved in a collision where you were not at-fault.

Why is lowering my coverage not a good idea to save money?

Technically, there are situations where lowering coverage can help you to save money and may be a recommended solution, such as if you had an older vehicle, but overall we recommend other routes for saving costs before cutting coverage. Switching to a reduced coverage option may seem like a good idea at first, but it can risk leaving you underinsured which, in the event of an accident, may end up costing you even more than it would if you had simply stayed sufficiently insured. The reason why cutting coverage may work for older vehicles is simply because older vehicles may cost more to repair or restore than they are worth. Speaking with a licensed insurance agent is the best place to get advice for your specific situation.