Most reliable car brands in Canada

Are you looking to purchase a new vehicle? You’re not alone. In 2024, almost 2 million new motor vehicles were sold in Canada, marking a 9.5% increase from 2023, according to Statistics Canada. But whether you’re shopping for your very first car or thinking it’s finally time for an upgrade, one thing matters above all else: reliability. Nobody wants to be stuck on the side of the road in the middle of a snowstorm, or at any time, really. And in Canada, where winters can be brutal and commutes can stretch for hours, having a dependable vehicle isn’t just nice to have; it’s essential.

So, what makes a car reliable? It starts with brand reputation. Some automakers have built a name for themselves by consistently producing vehicles that go the distance. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the most reliable car brands and explore what sets them apart.

Methodology for evaluating brand reliability

So, how do you actually figure out which car brands are the most reliable? It’s not just about what the salesperson tells you at the dealership or how a car feels during a test drive. Reliability is something that really shows itself over time, and to get a clear picture, we looked at trusted sources that specialize in tracking long-term performance across entire brands, not just individual models.

We started with Consumer Reports, one of the most respected names in the industry when it comes to vehicle reliability. It does in-depth studies that look at:

• How often vehicles need repairs

• What types of problems come up

• How satisfied owners are with their cars after months and years of use

Consumer Reports gathers data from hundreds of thousands of vehicle owners across North America. They analyze real-world feedback on everything from engine and transmission issues to problems with in-car tech and climate systems. Their latest survey highlights Subaru as the top brand for reliability, followed by Lexus and Toyota. When determining reliability, it’s also important to look at warranty claims and recall data, as they offer insight into how often things go wrong and how serious those issues are. And, of course, make sure to look at customer reviews and long-term ownership experiences shared online and through auto forums. These give a more personal, day-to-day perspective that’s often missing from the official stats.

Top 10 most reliable brands for 2025

When you’re shopping for a dependable car in Canada, reliability is essential. From frigid winters to long commutes across provinces, Canadian drivers need vehicles that can handle it all. Based on reliability ratings from Consumer Reports, here are the top 10 most reliable car brands, with a closer look at what makes each one stand out:

Subaru

Notable Subaru models: Outback, Forester, Crosstrek

For the first time, Subaru takes the top spot in Consumer Reports’ reliability rankings. A huge reason is their consistent engineering and conservative approach to redesigns. Subaru rarely overhauls its lineup, which means fewer surprises when it comes to performance.

But what really makes Subaru reliable is its mechanical simplicity and parts sharing across models. Many Subarus use the same engines, transmissions, and platforms, which helps the company refine and perfect those systems over time. Fewer changes mean fewer bugs to work out, and that leads to better reliability. Subaru’s signature Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system is also known for being durable and well-balanced, adding confidence in tough driving conditions.

Plus, Subarus are known for lasting well over 300,000 km with proper maintenance and have solid resale value in colder regions like Canada due to their AWD reputation and excellent winter handling.

Strengths

• Excellent AWD systems

• Great visibility

• Reliable engines

Common issues

Some older models had issues with oil consumption and CVT (continuously variable transmission) reliability, but recent improvements have addressed these.

Lexus

Notable Lexus models: RX, ES, NX

Lexus is consistently near the top of every reliability ranking. Their vehicles are known for quiet rides, strong resale value, and bulletproof engineering.

A big part of what makes Lexus so reliable is their conservative approach to innovation. They don’t rush out radical redesigns or untested tech; instead, they refine existing systems that are already proven to work. Under the hood, you’ll often find time-tested Toyota components, tuned for premium performance but with the same rock-solid dependability. Lexus also uses high-quality materials and manufacturing processes, which reduces the likelihood of defects or early wear.

AWD options and strong winter performance make Lexus a great, reliable luxury car in Canada. Many Lexus vehicles last 15+ years with few major repairs.

Strengths

• Smooth, quiet rides

• Low cost of ownership

• Minimal maintenance

Common issues

Occasionally, infotainment systems are cited as unintuitive.

Toyota

Notable Toyota models: Toyota Corolla, RAV4, Camry, Highlander, Avalon

Toyota’s reputation is built on reliability. Whether you’re looking at sedans or SUVs, Toyota delivers consistent quality. It’s no surprise to see models like the Corolla or RAV4 topping sales charts in Canada.

What makes Toyota so dependable is its focus on tried-and-true engineering. They don’t chase trends or rush into unproven technologies. Instead, they refine systems over time and prioritize long-term durability over flash. Toyota’s engines and transmissions are known for being simple, well-tested, and easy to maintain, which means fewer breakdowns and lower repair costs over the life of the vehicle.

On top of that, Toyota has one of the most rigorous quality control processes in the industry, catching issues before cars ever hit the lot. It’s this no-nonsense approach that helps their vehicles last well into the high-kilometre range and hold their value so well, especially in Canada, where reliability in tough conditions really matters.

Strengths

• Low maintenance costs

• Fuel efficiency

• Hybrid options

Common issues

Occasionally, infotainment systems are noted as being behind the curve, but otherwise, issues are rare.

Honda

Notable Honda models: CR-V, Civic, Accord

Honda pairs practicality with long-term dependability. It consistently scores high in owner satisfaction. Plus, Civics and CR-Vs are known to last 300,000+ kilometres and consistently rank among the best for resale value.

What makes Honda reliable comes down to a few key things: smart, efficient engineering and a focus on quality over complexity. Honda tends to build vehicles with well-balanced powertrains that are not only fuel-efficient but also remarkably durable. They also prioritize mechanical simplicity; fewer unnecessary features that can break down and more components that have been refined over decades.

Strengths

• Fuel efficiency

• Smart safety technology

• Well-rounded performance

Common issues

• Oil dilution in some turbo engines (mostly earlier versions)

Acura

Notable Acura models: RDX, MDX, Integra

Acura blends Honda reliability with luxury features, making it a great value for Canadians who want a premium experience without high maintenance bills. It offers high-mileage reliability and strong value retention. The RDX and MDX are both top-rated for long-term dependability.

What makes Acura reliable is its foundation. Many of its key components, like engines and transmissions, are shared with proven Honda models but tuned for a more refined feel. Acura also avoids overly complex tech in its drivetrains, which means fewer things that can go wrong over time. Plus, models like the MDX come with Super Handling All-Wheel Drive (SH-AWD), a system known not just for great winter performance but also for being durable and low-maintenance.

Strengths

• Strong resale

• Responsive engines

• Luxury interiors

Common issues

• Infotainment systems can be finicky

Mazda

Notable Mazda models: CX-5, Mazda3, CX-30

Mazda has quietly built a reputation for making stylish, fun-to-drive cars that also hold up well over time. Models like the CX-5, CX-50, and Mazda3 continue to score high in reliability, and the brand consistently ranks in the top tier of industry reports.

For Mazda, it comes down to smart engineering and a thoughtful approach to design. Mazda focuses on mechanical simplicity. Like Subaru, many of its models share the same engines and platforms, which cuts down on variability and makes it easier to refine and perfect those systems. They also avoid overly flashy tech that can lead to issues down the road, instead sticking with clean, driver-focused features that work well and last.

Strengths

• Excellent driving dynamics

• Upscale interiors

• Good fuel economy

Common issues

Some models have limited rear seat and cargo space. Also, some older models had rust concerns in high-salt areas, but newer models have improved corrosion protection.

Audi

Notable Audi models: Q5, A4, Q3

Audi brings a blend of luxury, performance, and sharp design. And in recent years, it’s also stepped up its game in terms of reliability. Popular models like the Q5, A4, and Q3 continue to improve in long-term dependability rankings, making Audi a more appealing choice for Canadian drivers who want luxury without constant trips to the shop.

Audi’s quattro all-wheel drive system is one of the most proven and capable AWD setups on the market, meaning it’s great for tackling Canada’s snow and ice. Audi has also streamlined its engine offerings, focusing on turbocharged four-cylinders that are both efficient and relatively dependable when properly maintained.

Strengths

• Quattro AWD system

• Refined interiors

• Advanced technology

Common issues

• Costly repairs if maintenance is neglected

• Electronics can sometimes be finicky

BMW

Notable BMW models: X3, 3 Series, X5

BMW is known for delivering a dynamic driving experience with plenty of luxury touches, and, in recent years, it’s also become more dependable than people might expect. Models like the 3 Series, X3, and X5 consistently rank among BMW’s most reliable offerings.

A big part of BMW’s jump in ranks for reliability comes down to the brand’s focus on engineering precision. BMW’s core drivetrains (especially their inline-six engines) are built to perform smoothly and last when properly maintained. Over the past few years, BMW has worked to simplify some of its tech and electronics, which were historically a weak spot. They’ve also improved their materials and assembly processes, cutting down on issues that used to crop up early in ownership.

Strengths

• Engaging driving experience

• Upscale interiors

Common issues

• Expensive repairs outside warranty

• Some models can have electrical issues

Kia

Notable Kia models: Sportage, Forte, Sorento

Kia has come a long way in a short time. Once seen as a budget brand, it’s now recognized for building stylish, well-equipped vehicles that hold up better than ever. Models like the Sportage, Seltos, Forte, and Sorento are consistently praised for their practicality, value, and improved reliability.

Kia has invested heavily in quality control and engineering over the past decade. Many of their newer models use shared platforms and engines developed with Hyundai, which means more consistency and fewer mechanical surprises. Kia also keeps its powertrains relatively simple, avoiding overly complex systems that can lead to reliability issues down the road.

Plus, their 5-year/100,000-kilometre warranty is one of the best in the business and shows the brand is confident in the long-term durability of its vehicles.

Strengths

• Excellent value

• Strong warranty coverage

• Solid tech features

Common issues

Some earlier models had engine issues, but recent years have shown strong improvement.

Hyundai

Notable Hyundai models: Tucson, Elantra, Santa Fe

Hyundai has built a strong reputation as a brand that delivers great value, modern design, and increasingly impressive reliability. Much like Kia (its corporate cousin), Hyundai focuses on proven engineering, streamlined manufacturing, and smart design choices that prioritize long-term durability. They’ve put a lot of effort into improving the quality of their powertrains and electronics in recent years, and it’s clearly paying off. Newer models are consistently ranking higher in reliability studies.

Hyundai also keeps its lineup practical, with powertrains that are efficient yet strong, and fewer overly complex features that might break down over time. Their Smartstream engine technology is designed with both performance and longevity in mind. And just like Kia, Hyundai backs up its vehicles with a standout 5-year/100,000-kilometre warranty.

Strengths

• User-friendly technology

• Strong safety ratings

• Strong warranty coverage

• Affordable pricing

Common issues

Past engine concerns and recalls have mostly been addressed, particularly in newer models.

What factors impact long-term reliability in vehicles?

When we talk about car reliability, we’re usually thinking about whether the vehicle will start up every morning, handle day-to-day driving without issues, and avoid major repairs over time. But what actually determines how reliable a car is in the long run? There’s no single answer. It’s a mix of design, maintenance, usage, road conditions, and even climate. Here are some of the biggest factors that impact a car’s long-term reliability:

Engineering and quality

At the core of reliability is how well a vehicle is designed and built. Brands that focus on mechanical simplicity, proven parts, and high-quality manufacturing tend to have fewer problems over time. Cars with overly complex systems or rushed redesigns are more likely to develop issues as they age. That’s why brands like Toyota and Honda, known for slow, steady updates, often top the charts.

Model history

Some models have years of refinement behind them, while others are brand new and still working out the kinks. Cars built on shared platforms with reliable engines and transmissions often benefit from proven performance and fewer design flaws.

Regular maintenance

Even the most well-built car won’t last long without proper maintenance. Following the manufacturer’s recommended service schedule for oil changes, fluid flushes, and brake service can prevent small issues from turning into major headaches. Skipping routine care is one of the fastest ways to shorten a car’s lifespan. If your car is due for service, contact a trusted mechanic.

Driving habits

How you drive plays a big role, too. Aggressive acceleration, heavy braking, towing beyond capacity, or constant stop-and-go city driving can wear down components faster. On the other hand, smooth, consistent driving and acceleration can help everything from the engine to the transmission last much longer.

Road conditions

Where you drive is just as important as how you drive. Potholes, rough rural roads, gravel, and poorly maintained city streets can cause extra wear and tear on suspension, tires, and alignment. If you regularly drive in areas with uneven or rugged terrain, vehicles with durable suspensions, higher ground clearance, or off-road capability are going to last longer and break down less.

Climate

Canadian winters are no joke, and extreme weather can take a toll on a vehicle. Cold starts, road salt, ice, and constant freeze-thaw cycles can affect everything from the battery to the suspension to the undercarriage. Cars with good cold-weather performance, rust protection, and AWD systems tend to fare better here.

How a reliable car can help lower your car insurance premium

There are plenty of good reasons to choose a reliable car: it’s safer, it lasts longer, and it gives you peace of mind on the road. But here’s one more reason you might not have thought of: reliable cars can actually help lower your car insurance premium. Here's why:

Reliability and car insurance

When insurance companies calculate your rate, they look at a lot of different factors, including the make, model, and year of your vehicle. These details help them figure out how safe and dependable your car really is. Whether it’s a new or used car, if your vehicle has a strong track record for reliability and safety, it’s seen as less risky to insure. That often translates into lower premiums. Reliable cars are less likely to break down unexpectedly, and if they’re involved in an accident, the damage tends to be less severe—both to the vehicle and to the people inside it. According to Consumer Reports, cars (including sedans, hatchbacks and wagons) are the most reliable vehicle type, followed by minivans, then SUVs, and pickup trucks came in last.

Other factors

That said, reliability isn’t the only thing your insurer considers when it comes to your vehicle. They’ll also look at things like how expensive your car is to repair or replace. If you’re driving a high-end vehicle, the cost of parts and labour tends to be higher, which can drive up your insurance rate. And if your car model happens to be a target for theft, that could impact your premium, too. So, while picking a reliable car can definitely work in your favour when it comes to car insurance, it’s always good to look at the bigger picture.

Call BrokerLink to learn more about your insurance rates

If you have questions about how reliability can impact your car insurance premium, contact a BrokerLink car insurance broker today. BrokerLink is made up of licensed and friendly professionals who know the ins and outs of the auto insurance industry. We can give you tips on purchasing a new car, information on how to know a reliable car from an unreliable one, and invaluable insight into reliable electric cars if you’re looking to purchase an EV.

If you’re ready to speak with a broker, call BrokerLink today. We can also be reached by email or in person at any one of our branches across Canada. We look forward to hearing from you!